All-time best penalty takers
| # | Name | Matches | 11m | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  | Michael McIndoe | 138 | 18 |
| 2 |  | Joe Ironside | 106 | 8 |
 | Billy Sharp | 198 | 8 | |
 | Nathan Tyson | 80 | 8 | |
| 5 |  | Brian Stock | 210 | 7 |
 | Ben Whiteman | 157 | 7 | |
| 7 |  | Chris Brown | 117 | 5 |
 | Luke Molyneux | 209 | 5 | |
| 9 |  | Paul Heffernan | 150 | 4 |
 | Liam Mandeville | 56 | 4 | |
| 11 |  | James Coppinger | 688 | 3 |
 | James Hayter | 178 | 3 | |
 | John Marquis | 151 | 3 | |
 | Niall Mason | 111 | 3 | |
 | Billy Paynter | 51 | 3 | |
 | Andy Williams | 101 | 3 | |
| 17 |  | El-Hadji Diouf | 23 | 2 |
 | George Miller | 41 | 2 | |
 | Fejiri Okenabirhie | 51 | 2 | |
 | Tommy Rowe | 264 | 2 | |
 | Martin Woods | 135 | 2 | |
| 22 |  | Paul Barnes | 12 | 1 |
 | Omar Bogle | 28 | 1 | |
 | Dan Gardner | 23 | 1 | |
 | Lewis Guy | 176 | 1 | |
 | Elliot Lee | 18 | 1 | |
 | Curtis Main | 58 | 1 | |
 | Ross McCormack | 19 | 1 | |
 | Jamie Paterson | 11 | 1 | |
 | Theo Robinson | 72 | 1 | |
 | Dean Shiels | 88 | 1 | |
 | Lee Tomlin | 10 | 1 |