Head to head
- Matches
- 16
- Wins York City
- 6
- Wins Grimsby Town
- 7
- Draws
- 3
- Score
- 20 : 26
Höchste Siege
| League Two 2026/2027 | 31.10.2026 | Grimsby Town - York City | GRI - YOR | 5:2 |
| League Cup 1978/1979 | 15.08.1978 | York City - Grimsby Town | YOR - GRI | 0:3 |
| FA Cup 1971/1972 | 20.11.1971 | York City - Grimsby Town | YOR - GRI | 4:2 |
| League Cup 1983/1984 | 13.09.1983 | Grimsby Town - York City | GRI - YOR | 2:0 |
| League Cup 1978/1979 | 12.08.1978 | Grimsby Town - York City | GRI - YOR | 2:0 |


