Additions
| from | Name | Pos | Team | Team | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 09/2026 |  | Alan Torres | FW | |||
| 07/2026 |  | Jorge Salmeron | MF |  | Columbus Crew U16 | U16 |
| 06/2026 | | Jackson Bonos | MF | |||
| 05/2026 | | Cole Mrowka | MF |  | Columbus Crew | Columbus Crew |
| 05/2026 | | Immanuel Ewing | FW | |||
| 05/2026 |  | Chris Rogers | AS-CO | |||
| 03/2026 | | Tarun Karumanchi | MF | | Columbus Crew | Columbus Crew |
| 02/2026 |  | Rui Aoki | DF | |||
| 02/2026 | | Johann Chirinos | MF |  | FC Ingolstadt 04 II | Ingolstadt II |
| 02/2026 |  | Moses Nyeman | MF |  | Loudoun United | Loudoun United |
| 02/2026 | | Isaac Heffess | DF | | Columbus Crew | Columbus Crew |
| 01/2026 | | Zach Zengue | MF | | Columbus Crew | Columbus Crew |
| 01/2026 | | O'Neal Taylor | ||||
| 01/2026 | | Keller Abbott | GK | | Columbus Crew U16 | U16 |
| 01/2026 | | Luke Pruter | GK |  | Indy Eleven | Indy Eleven |
| 01/2026 | | Alex Zochowski | GK | |||
| 01/2026 | | Zach Lloyd | DF | |||
| 01/2026 | | Owen Presthus | DF |  | Hartford Athletic | Hartford Athl. |
| 01/2026 | | Giorgio de Libera | MF | |||
| 01/2026 | | Jamil Danjaji | FW | | Columbus Crew U16 | U16 |
| 01/2026 | | Alex Gimple | FW |
Departures
| from | Name | Pos | Team | Team | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 08/2026 | | Owen Presthus | DF |  | Nashville SC | Nashville SC |
| 07/2026 |  | Inza Koné | FW |  | Paris 13 Atletico | Paris 13 At. |
| 07/2026 | | Zach Zengue | MF |  | St. Louis City SC | St. Louis City |
| 07/2026 | | Austin Su | MF |  | Michigan Wolverines | Michigan Wolverines |
| 07/2026 | | Alex Gimple | FW | | Michigan Wolverines | Michigan Wolverines |
| 02/2026 | | Josh Williams | AS-CO | | Columbus Crew | Columbus Crew |
| 01/2026 |  | Keesean Ferdinand | DF |  | FC Supra du Québec | FC Supra du Québec |
| 01/2026 |  | Malcom Palacios | DF |  | Independiente Medellín | Medellín |
| 01/2026 | | Cristian Ortiz | FW |  | Tampa Bay Rowdies | Tampa Bay |