Gameplan
| Date | Round | Match | Match | Res. | Attendance | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 07.03.2026 |  | Matchday 3 | NY City FC - Orlando City | NYC - ORL | 5:0 | 25.055 |
| 15.03.2026 | | Matchday 4 | NY City FC - Colorado Rapids | NYC - COR | 3:1 | 18.079 |
| 22.03.2026 | | Matchday 5 | NY City FC - Inter Miami | NYC - MIA | 2:3 | 45.845 |
| 23.04.2026 | | Matchday 9 | NY City FC - Cincinnati | NYC - CIN | 4:4 | 17.847 |
| 10.05.2026 | | Matchday 12 | NY City FC - Columbus Crew | NYC - COC | 3:0 | 17.770 |
| 26.07.2026 | | Matchday 17 | NY City FC - Chicago Fire | NYC - CHI | 3:1 | 27.419 |
| 01.08.2026 | | Matchday 18 | NY City FC - Toronto FC | NYC - TOR | 1:1 | 21.085 |
| 17.08.2026 | | Matchday 19 | NY City FC - Philadelphia | NYC - PHI | 2:3 | 20.034 |
| 05.09.2026 | | Matchday 23 | NY City FC - Nashville SC | NYC - NSC | 0:0 | 20.393 |
| 19.09.2026 | | Matchday 26 | NY City FC - New York RB | NYC - RB | 0:1 | 29.270 |
| 29.10.2026 | | Matchday 32 | NY City FC - Atlanta United | NYC - ATL | 2:1 | 17.699 |
| 31.10.2026 | | Matchday 33 | NY City FC - Montréal | NYC - MON | 1:1 | 17.522 |