Record by referee Terry Vaughn
| Competition | Date | Match | Match | Res. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Major League Soccer | 05.08.2007 | Chicago Fire - Columbus Crew | CHI - COC | 0:0 |
| Major League Soccer | 21.10.2007 | DC United - Columbus Crew | DCU - COC | 2:3 |
| Major League Soccer | 27.04.2008 | Columbus Crew - H. Dynamo | COC - HOU | 1:0 |
| Major League Soccer | 15.06.2008 | Kansas City - Columbus Crew | SKC - COC | 0:3 |
| Major League Soccer | 24.08.2008 | Columbus Crew - Salt Lake | COC - RSL | 3:0 |
| Major League Soccer | 28.09.2008 | New Engl. - Columbus Crew | NER - COC | 0:1 |
| Major League Soccer | 14.11.2008 | Columbus Crew - Chicago Fire | COC - CHI | 2:1 |
| Major League Soccer | 27.09.2009 | Columbus Crew - L.A. Galaxy | COC - LAG | 2:0 |
| Major League Soccer | 27.06.2010 | Columbus Crew - DC United | COC - DCU | 2:0 |
| Major League Soccer | 01.05.2011 | Columbus Crew - Vancouver | COC - VAN | 2:1 |
