Titles as a player
| 3 x English Champion | ||
|---|---|---|
| 1892 | ![]() | Sunderland AFC |
| 1893 | ![]() | Sunderland AFC |
| 1895 | ![]() | Sunderland AFC |
| 1 x Scottish Champion | ||
| 1904 | ![]() | Third Lanark |

| 3 x English Champion | ||
|---|---|---|
| 1892 | ![]() | Sunderland AFC |
| 1893 | ![]() | Sunderland AFC |
| 1895 | ![]() | Sunderland AFC |
| 1 x Scottish Champion | ||
| 1904 | ![]() | Third Lanark |