Titles as a player
| 2 x English Champion | ||
|---|---|---|
| 1908 |  | Manchester United |
| 1911 | | Manchester United |
| 2 x Championship Champion | ||
| 1898/1899 |  | Manchester City |
| 1902/1903 | | Manchester City |
| 2 x English Cup Winner | ||
| 1904 | | Manchester City |
| 1909 | | Manchester United |
| 2 x English Super Cup Winner | ||
| 1908 | | Manchester United |
| 1911 | | Manchester United |