Court ruling: Rangers face title stripping

Scottish record champions Rangers FC face the removal of all titles won between 2001 and 2011. A court determined that the employee benefit trust used by Rangers constituted hidden salary payments.
The competition, however, has mixed feelings about the ruling. Three years after insolvency and the subsequent forced demotion to the fourth division, the case of Glasgow's traditional club Rangers continues to cause turmoil. A court judgment in the tax proceedings surrounding the financial irregularities of the 54-time Scottish champions identified the use of an Employee Benefit Trust as hidden salary payments to players.
Particularly noteworthy was the determination by one of the three judges, Lord Drummond Young, that had the trust not existed, some players would have worked elsewhere. Consequently, the league and governing body must now also address the issue of competitive imbalance. The removal of all titles won during the disputed period (2001 to 2011) is under consideration. Specifically, this concerns five league championships, four cup victories, and six League Cup successes.
Rangers officials announced they intend to fight against the possible deletion of these achievements from their history. City rival Celtic, however, welcomes the title stripping. Other club representatives, though, warn against hasty action.
The Telegraph newspaper quoted an unnamed club executive who stated that clubs believe this matter must be handled very carefully due to the possible consequences. He noted that if they strip Rangers of their titles on principle and award them to the runners-up, this would trigger bonus payments.
Entry into the record books comes with a price
Celtic could cover the resulting costs through success bonuses for five additional league titles, one cup, and two League Cup victories, but the financially struggling remaining Scottish clubs likely could not. Cup finalists Dundee FC (2003), Queen of South (2008), and Falkirk (2009), as well as League Cup finalists Ayr (2002), Motherwell (2005), Dundee United (2008), and St. Mirren (2010) would be affected parties who must address the issue.
The unnamed club executive further stated in the Telegraph that the alternative would be not to award the trophies and devalue their competitions at a time when they must seek sponsors with their hands out. It remains unclear what European consequences a stripping of Rangers titles would entail. Would UEFA funds distributed to Scottish clubs need to be repaid?
While these questions are being considered for such a scenario, the ball is in Rangers' court. To proceed to another instance in the major tax case, an appeal must be filed within three weeks. The record champions, currently competing in the second division, can thus expect further legal complications. Following the takeover of Rangers by majority shareholder Dave King, a power struggle is also raging at the legal level with sports retail billionaire Mike Ashley.





