Today Livesearchsearch

World Cup

Therefore, there should be no surprise...

FIFA defends worst World Cup decision

FIFA defends worst World Cup decision
01. July 2026, 09:10

The goal ultimately disallowed by VAR that would have made it 2:1, with which Jonathan Tah allowed the German national football team to briefly dream of victory in extra time during the round of 16 at the World Cup in the USA, Mexico and Canada, generated almost as much criticism in retrospect as the performance of the DFB side, which ultimately exited in a penalty shootout against Paraguay. FIFA has now responded to the decision.

The much-discussed decision not to award Jonathan Tah's goal in the World Cup round of 16 match against Paraguay was correct, according to FIFA referee chief Pierluigi Collina. Collina stated that coaches and players had been informed about this. He emphasized that there should therefore be no surprise when referees penalize such offenses.

FIFA had recommended to referees beforehand to pay special attention to certain situations that can occur in connection with the tactical approaches of individual teams. One example cited was when attacking players attempt to obstruct defending players in their movement.

In the specific case, the behavior of substitute Waldemar Anton triggered VAR intervention. The Borussia Dortmund defender allegedly unlawfully obstructed Paraguay goalkeeper Orlando Gill after a corner from Nathaniel Brown, thereby paving the way for Tah's goal. An assessment that Anton himself described as an outrage. The DFB side had planned a goalkeeper block in the situation, a tactic that many teams have recently employed as a tactical tool.

FIFA referee chief defends complete scandal

Among others, Jürgen Klopp pointed to Arsenal after Germany's elimination, noting that the club perfected this tactic in the previous season. Klopp argued that if this goal was irregular, then Arsenal would not be English champions, stating he believed they scored 60 percent of their goals in this manner, criticizing FIFA's intervention.

Collina wrote in his statement that FIFA interprets the rules somewhat differently. He explained that if an attacking player has no interest in the ball and moves, even only slightly, with the clear intention of obstructing an opponent's running movement and thereby preventing them from defending, referees and, if necessary, VAR should carefully analyze the situation and intervene. He emphasized this applies especially when this tactic aims to prevent the opposing goalkeeper from effectively defending the goal.

In Germany, however, numerous experts made clear that this was a wrong decision. Federal coach Julian Nagelsmann spoke of a complete scandal, and English radio station talkSPORT even headlined: FIFA owes Germany a massive apology. The outlet called it the worst wrong decision of the 2026 World Cup, stating it had ruined the match.

This content was originally written by our editorial team and automatically translated into English supported by AI technology.