Head to head
- Matches
- 27
- Wins Grimsby Town
- 8
- Wins Everton FC
- 15
- Draws
- 4
- Score
- 38 : 62
Höchste Siege
| Premier League 1935/1936 | 28.03.1936 | Everton - Grimsby Town | EVE - GRI | 4:0 |
| Premier League 1935/1936 | 23.11.1935 | Grimsby Town - Everton | GRI - EVE | 0:4 |
| FA Cup 1934/1935 | 12.01.1935 | Everton - Grimsby Town | EVE - GRI | 6:3 |
| FA Cup 1947/1948 | 10.01.1948 | Grimsby Town - Everton | GRI - EVE | 1:4 |
| Premier League 1947/1948 | 26.03.1948 | Grimsby Town - Everton | GRI - EVE | 3:0 |


