Head to head
- Matches
- 36
- Wins Oldham Athletic
- 11
- Wins Plymouth Argyle
- 15
- Draws
- 10
- Score
- 56 : 67
Höchste Siege
| Championship 1953/1954 | 16.01.1954 | Plymouth - Oldham Athletic | PLY - OLD | 5:0 |
| Championship 1931/1932 | 28.03.1932 | Plymouth - Oldham Athletic | PLY - OLD | 5:0 |
| League One 2017/2018 | 23.12.2017 | Plymouth - Oldham Athletic | PLY - OLD | 4:1 |
| League One 2003/2004 | 17.04.2004 | Oldham Athletic - Plymouth | OLD - PLY | 4:1 |
| Championship 1988/1989 | 26.11.1988 | Plymouth - Oldham Athletic | PLY - OLD | 3:0 |


