Head to head
- Matches
- 15
- Wins Aston Villa
- 8
- Wins Plymouth Argyle
- 3
- Draws
- 4
- Score
- 37 : 22
Höchste Siege
| FA Cup 1905/1906 | 07.02.1906 | Plymouth - Aston Villa | PLY - AVL | 1:5 |
| Championship 1987/1988 | 27.02.1988 | Aston Villa - Plymouth | AVL - PLY | 5:2 |
| Championship 1959/1960 | 30.04.1960 | Plymouth - Aston Villa | PLY - AVL | 3:0 |
| Championship 1937/1938 | 23.02.1938 | Aston Villa - Plymouth | AVL - PLY | 3:0 |
| Championship 1937/1938 | 02.10.1937 | Plymouth - Aston Villa | PLY - AVL | 0:3 |
All matches
| Championship 1987/1988 | 27.02.1988 | Aston Villa - Plymouth | AVL - PLY | 5:2 |
| Championship 1987/1988 | 03.10.1987 | Plymouth - Aston Villa | PLY - AVL | 1:3 |
| Championship 1967/1968 | 28.08.1967 | Aston Villa - Plymouth | AVL - PLY | 0:1 |
| Championship 1967/1968 | 23.08.1967 | Plymouth - Aston Villa | PLY - AVL | 2:1 |
| League Cup 1960/1961 | 06.02.1961 | Aston Villa - Plymouth | AVL - PLY | 5:3 |
| League Cup 1960/1961 | 19.12.1960 | Plymouth - Aston Villa | PLY - AVL | 0:0 |
| League Cup 1960/1961 | 13.12.1960 | Aston Villa - Plymouth | AVL - PLY | 3:3 |
| Championship 1959/1960 | 30.04.1960 | Plymouth - Aston Villa | PLY - AVL | 3:0 |
| Championship 1959/1960 | 31.10.1959 | Aston Villa - Plymouth | AVL - PLY | 2:0 |
| Championship 1937/1938 | 23.02.1938 | Aston Villa - Plymouth | AVL - PLY | 3:0 |
| Championship 1937/1938 | 02.10.1937 | Plymouth - Aston Villa | PLY - AVL | 0:3 |
| Championship 1936/1937 | 13.02.1937 | Aston Villa - Plymouth | AVL - PLY | 5:4 |
| Championship 1936/1937 | 10.10.1936 | Plymouth - Aston Villa | PLY - AVL | 2:2 |
| FA Cup 1905/1906 | 07.02.1906 | Plymouth - Aston Villa | PLY - AVL | 1:5 |
| FA Cup 1905/1906 | 03.02.1906 | Aston Villa - Plymouth | AVL - PLY | 0:0 |


