Head to head
- Matches
- 23
- Wins Arbroath FC
- 7
- Wins Alloa Athletic
- 11
- Draws
- 5
- Score
- 28 : 38
Höchste Siege
| Challenge Cup 2014/2015 | 26.07.2014 | Arbroath FC - Alloa Ath. | Arb - ALL | 1:4 |
| League One 2017/2018 | 06.03.2018 | Alloa Ath. - Arbroath FC | ALL - Arb | 5:3 |
| League Cup 2018/2019 | 17.07.2018 | Alloa Ath. - Arbroath FC | ALL - Arb | 4:2 |
| League One 2024/2025 | 04.01.2025 | Arbroath FC - Alloa Ath. | Arb - ALL | 1:3 |
| Championship 2019/2020 | 21.01.2020 | Alloa Ath. - Arbroath FC | ALL - Arb | 2:0 |


