Record winners

Title		Team
6		Greek American AA
5		Maccabi Los Angeles
5		Fall River Marksmen
5		Bethlehem Steel (old)
4		Sporting Kansas City
4		Seattle Sounders
4		Chicago Fire
4		Ukrainian Nationals
3		D.C. United
3		N.Y. Pancyprian-Freedoms
2		Houston Dynamo
2		FC Dallas
2		Los Angeles Galaxy
2		Kutis S.C.
2		Elizabeth S.C.
2		Los Angeles Kickers
2		New York Hungaria
2		Hammarville FC
2		New York American FC
2		St. Louis Simpkens
2		Brooklyn Hispano
2		Fuller St. Louis
1		St. Louis City SC
1		Nashville SC
1		Los Angeles FC
1		Orlando City
1		Atlanta United FC
1		New England Revolution
1		Columbus Crew
1		Rochester NYFC
1		Richmond Kickers
1		C.D. Mexico
1		San Jose Oaks
1		Brooklyn Italian S.C.
1		A.A.C. Eagles
1		H.R.C. Kickers
1		Busch S.C.
1		Club España
1		A.O. Krete
1		Brooklyn Dodgers S.C.
1		San Francisco A.C.
1		Hota S.C.
1		NY Ukrainians
1		McIlvaine Canvasbacks
1		Eintracht Sport Club
1		Falcons S.C.
1		Morgan SC
1		Ponta Delgada S.C.
1		Chicago Vikings
1		New York Brookhattan
1		Gallatin S.C.
1		Pawtucket F.C.
1		Baltimore Canton
1		St. Mary's Celtics SC
1		Chicago Sparta A.B.A.
1		German-Americans Philadelphia
1		Central Breweries St. Louis
1		New Bedford Whalers
1		New York Hakoah
1		New York Nationals
1		Shawsheen Indians
1		Paterson F.C.
1		Scullin Steel F.C
1		Robbins Dry Dock FC
1		St. Louis Ben Millers
1		Brooklyn Field Club