| Goalkeeper | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name | Country | Birthday | ||
 | James Kirkpatrick |  | Scotland | 22.03.1841 † |
| Defence | ||||
| Name | Country | Birthday | ||
 | Francis Birley |  | England | 14.03.1850 † |
| Midfield | ||||
| Name | Country | Birthday | ||
 | Arthur Kinnaird | | Scotland | 16.02.1847 † |
 | Julian Sturgis | | England | 21.10.1848 † |
| Forward | ||||
| Name | Country | Birthday | ||
 | Charles Alcock | | England | 02.12.1842 † |
 | John Edwards |  | Wales | 21.03.1850 † |
 | George Heron | | England | 30.01.1852 † |
 | Charles Wollaston | | England | 31.07.1849 † |
 | John Wylie | | England | 05.10.1854 † |
The Wanderers