Gameplan
| Date | Round | Match | Match | Res. | Attendance | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16.04.2023 | ![]() | Matchday 3 | NY City FC - Nashville SC | NYC - NSC | 2:1 | 18.687 |
| 23.04.2023 | ![]() | Matchday 3 | NY City FC - FC Dallas | NYC - DAL | 3:1 | 20.922 |
| 28.05.2023 | ![]() | Matchday 4 | NY City FC - Philadelphia | NYC - PHI | 1:3 | 22.830 |
| 06.07.2023 | ![]() | Matchday 6 | NY City FC - Charlotte | NYC - CLT | 1:1 | 15.122 |
| 24.07.2023 | ![]() | Group 14 | NY City FC - Atlas | NYC - Atl | 0:1 | 22.267 |
| 21.08.2023 | ![]() | Matchday 7 | NY City FC - Minnesota Utd | NYC - MIN | 0:2 | 18.606 |
| 21.09.2023 | ![]() | Matchday 8 | NY City FC - Orlando City | NYC - ORL | 2:0 | 15.238 |
| 22.10.2023 | ![]() | Matchday 9 | NY City FC - Chicago Fire | NYC - CHI | 1:0 | 23.260 |

