Matches against Chicago Fire
| Season | Date | Match | Match | Res. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Major League Soccer 2026 | 10.10.2026 | Chicago Fire - NY City FC | CHI - NYC | 2:1 |
| Major League Soccer 2026 | 26.07.2026 | NY City FC - Chicago Fire | NYC - CHI | 3:1 |
| Major League Soccer 2025 | 14.09.2025 | Chicago Fire - NY City FC | CHI - NYC | 1:3 |
| Major League Soccer 2025 | 25.05.2025 | NY City FC - Chicago Fire | NYC - CHI | 3:1 |

