Record by referee Lee Probert
| Competition | Date | Match | Match | Res. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Premier League | 23.09.2007 | Aston Villa - Everton | AVL - EVE | 2:0 |
| Premier League | 20.01.2008 | Wigan - Everton | WIG - EVE | 1:2 |
| Premier League | 30.08.2009 | Everton - Wigan | EVE - WIG | 2:1 |
| Premier League | 30.01.2010 | Wigan - Everton | WIG - EVE | 0:1 |
| Premier League | 05.01.2011 | Everton - Tottenham | EVE - TOT | 2:1 |
| Premier League | 13.02.2011 | Bolton - Everton | BOL - EVE | 2:0 |
| Premier League | 23.10.2011 | Fulham - Everton | FUL - EVE | 1:3 |
| Premier League | 17.12.2011 | Everton - Norwich City | EVE - NOR | 1:1 |
| Premier League | 29.09.2012 | Everton - Southampton | EVE - SOU | 3:1 |
| Premier League | 01.12.2012 | Man City - Everton | MCI - EVE | 1:1 |
| Premier League | 16.03.2013 | Everton - Man City | EVE - MCI | 2:0 |
| Premier League | 26.12.2013 | Everton - Sunderland | EVE - SUN | 0:1 |
| Premier League | 22.02.2014 | Chelsea - Everton | CHE - EVE | 1:0 |
| Premier League | 12.04.2014 | Sunderland - Everton | SUN - EVE | 0:1 |
| Premier League | 03.05.2014 | Everton - Man City | EVE - MCI | 2:3 |
| Premier League | 09.05.2015 | Everton - Sunderland | EVE - SUN | 0:2 |
| FA Cup | 27.03.2012 | Sunderland - Everton | SUN - EVE | 0:2 |