Record by referee Michael Riley
| Competition | Date | Match | Match | Res. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Premier League | 22.11.2003 | Everton - Wolverhampton | EVE - WOL | 2:0 |
| Premier League | 01.05.2004 | Wolverhampton - Everton | WOL - EVE | 2:1 |
| Premier League | 15.08.2004 | Everton - Arsenal | EVE - ARS | 1:4 |
| Premier League | 06.11.2004 | Chelsea - Everton | CHE - EVE | 1:0 |
| Premier League | 27.08.2005 | Fulham - Everton | FUL - EVE | 1:0 |
| Premier League | 26.12.2005 | Aston Villa - Everton | AVL - EVE | 4:0 |
| Premier League | 04.03.2006 | West Ham - Everton | WHU - EVE | 2:2 |
| Premier League | 28.10.2006 | Arsenal - Everton | ARS - EVE | 1:1 |
| Premier League | 14.01.2007 | Everton - Reading FC | EVE - REA | 1:1 |
| Premier League | 03.03.2007 | Sheffield Utd - Everton | SHE - EVE | 1:1 |
| Premier League | 25.08.2007 | Everton - Blackburn | EVE - BLA | 1:1 |
| Premier League | 03.11.2007 | Everton - Birmingham | EVE - BIR | 3:1 |
| Premier League | 27.09.2008 | Everton - Liverpool | EVE - LIV | 0:2 |
| Premier League | 24.05.2009 | Fulham - Everton | FUL - EVE | 0:2 |
| FA Cup | 19.04.2009 | Man Utd - Everton | MUN - EVE | 2:4 |
