Matches against FC Cincinnati
| Season | Date | Match | Match | Res. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Major League Soccer 2022 | 08.09.2022 | NY City FC - Cincinnati | NYC - CIN | 1:1 |
| Major League Soccer 2022 | 30.06.2022 | Cincinnati - NY City FC | CIN - NYC | 4:4 |

| Season | Date | Match | Match | Res. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Major League Soccer 2022 | 08.09.2022 | NY City FC - Cincinnati | NYC - CIN | 1:1 |
| Major League Soccer 2022 | 30.06.2022 | Cincinnati - NY City FC | CIN - NYC | 4:4 |