Matches against Chicago Fire
| Season | Date | Match | Match | Res. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Major League Soccer 2011 | 23.10.2011 | Chicago Fire - Columbus Crew | CHI - COC | 3:2 |
| Major League Soccer 2011 | 12.06.2011 | Columbus Crew - Chicago Fire | COC - CHI | 0:1 |
| Major League Soccer 2010 | 09.10.2010 | Chicago Fire - Columbus Crew | CHI - COC | 2:0 |
| Major League Soccer 2010 | 04.07.2010 | Columbus Crew - Chicago Fire | COC - CHI | 2:1 |
| Major League Soccer 2009 | 20.09.2009 | Chicago Fire - Columbus Crew | CHI - COC | 2:2 |
| Major League Soccer 2009 | 12.07.2009 | Chicago Fire - Columbus Crew | CHI - COC | 0:0 |
| Major League Soccer 2008 Playoffs | 14.11.2008 | Columbus Crew - Chicago Fire | COC - CHI | 2:1 |
| Major League Soccer 2008 | 12.10.2008 | Chicago Fire - Columbus Crew | CHI - COC | 2:2 |
| Major League Soccer 2008 | 06.07.2008 | Columbus Crew - Chicago Fire | COC - CHI | 2:2 |
| Major League Soccer 2007 | 09.09.2007 | Columbus Crew - Chicago Fire | COC - CHI | 0:1 |
| Major League Soccer 2007 | 05.08.2007 | Chicago Fire - Columbus Crew | CHI - COC | 0:0 |
| Major League Soccer 2006 | 05.07.2006 | Chicago Fire - Kansas City | CHI - SKC | 1:0 |
