Record by referee Machenbach CompetitionDateMatchMatchRes.Oberliga West (1947-63)24.10.1954Schalke - KölnS04 - KOE2:1Oberliga West (1947-63)19.02.1956Köln - SchalkeKOE - S043:2Oberliga West (1947-63)11.01.1959Schalke - BochumS04 - BOC1:0