Matches against Notts County
| Season | Date | Match | Match | Res. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Premier League 1890/1891 | 03.01.1891 | Everton - Notts County | EVE - NOT | 4:2 |
| Premier League 1890/1891 | 01.11.1890 | Notts County - Everton | NOT - EVE | 3:1 |
| Premier League 1889/1890 | 07.12.1889 | Everton - Notts County | EVE - NOT | 5:3 |
| Premier League 1889/1890 | 19.10.1889 | Notts County - Everton | NOT - EVE | 4:3 |
